Big Island Video News

Serving Hawaii County

  • Hawaiʻi Island News Regions
    • Hāmākua
      • Mauna Kea
    • Hilo
    • Kaʻū
    • Kona
    • Kohala
    • Puna

Video from livestream by U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, presented with graphics by Big Island Video News.

VIDEO: Fight Over Big Island GMO Ban Argued In Federal Court
Big Island Video News

by Big Island Video News
on Jun 16, 2016 at 8:34 am

Subscribe to Big Island Video News (FREE)

* indicates required

STORY SUMMARY

HONOLULU (BIVN) - After a federal judge invalidated a controversial ban on genetically modified organisms in Hawaii County, the county council decided to appeal and accepted the help of Earthjustice lawyers. They had their day in court Wednesday.

HONOLULU, Hawaii – Attorneys on either side of the Big Island’s GMO fight made their case before federal court judges on Wednesday.

Hawaii County is appealing a federal court decision that overturned its ban on genetically engineered crops.

At the heart of the matter is preemption; when state law conflicts with federal law, the United States law serves as law of the land. At the same time, if county law conflicts with state law, state law prevails.

On November 26, U.S. Magistrate Judge Barry Kurren ruled in favor of a group of plaintiffs (led by the Hawaii Papaya Industry Association) seeking to invalidate Hawaii County Ordinance 13-121, a law passed by the Hawaii County Council in 2013 restricting the cultivation of new Genetically Modified Organisms on Hawaii Island.

Kurren agreed with plaintiffs that the county ordinance is expressly preempted by federal law, citing the federal Plant Protection Act, “but only to the extent that express federal preemption applies to the Ordinance’s ban on field testing of genetically engineered plants that are ‘plant pests’ or ‘noxious weeds’”. The Court did not to find that the GMO ban “is impliedly preempted” by federal law. The judge also agreed that a state preemption applies.

Judge Kurren also enjoined a similar Kauai County law on pesticides and genetically modified crops. A GMO moratorium on Maui was also thrown out.

On December 17, the Hawaii County Council voted to appeal. Paul Achitoff, managing attorney for the Earthjustice mid-Pacific regional office, offered to help the county going forward.

All three counties presented their oral arguments back to back in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in Honolulu on Wednesday.


Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Bill 113, GMO, Paul Achitoff

LATEST NEWS

Hawaii COVID-19 Monday Update: Lab Detects SARS-CoV-2 Variant

Hawaii COVID-19 Monday Update: Lab Detects SARS-CoV-2 Variant

Flash Flood Warning For Kaʻū, Highway 11 Closed

Flash Flood Warning For Kaʻū, Highway 11 Closed

Flood Advisory For East Hawaii, Winter Storm Warning For Summits

Flood Advisory For East Hawaii, Winter Storm Warning For Summits

Winter Storm Watch For Hawaii Summits, Foot Of Snow Possible

Winter Storm Watch For Hawaii Summits, Foot Of Snow Possible

Hawaii COVID-19 Saturday Update: 134 New Cases Statewide

Hawaii COVID-19 Saturday Update: 134 New Cases Statewide

High Surf, Wind, Heavy Rain Possible For Hawaiʻi Island

High Surf, Wind, Heavy Rain Possible For Hawaiʻi Island

About Big Island Video News

  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 · Dynamik Website Builder on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in